Usually the contractor, through its general liability insurance. When a crew you hired damages your rental while it works, the claim goes to the contractor first, in writing, with photos of the damage and proof of how the unit looked before the job. Whether their policy pays depends on its terms. Your own policy covers your building, not your tenant's belongings, and Airbnb's damage protection is for damage by guests. Without a dated record of the unit before the crew arrived, every one of those claims gets harder.

Every landlord, property manager and short-term rental operator sends trades into their units: a plumber for a leak, a painter between tenants, an HVAC crew for a new system, a flooring team during the off season. Most jobs end fine. When one doesn't, there is a gouged floor, a stained carpet in the hallway, a cracked counter or a ceiling stain under the new fixture, and the crew's first answer can be that it was already there. This page is for the owner or manager in that moment.

This is general information, not legal advice. Who owes what depends on your contract, your lease and your state's law.

What to do before anyone fixes anything

  1. Make it safe, then stop. Shut off water or power if the damage needs it, then leave the damage as it is until it is recorded. A quick quiet repair by the crew erases your evidence.
  2. Record it the same day. Wide photos that show where the damage sits in the room, then close-ups, then a short video. Record the crew's work area and the path they used to get in: hallways, stairs, door frames, the floor between the door and the job.
  3. Get the contractor's details. Business name, license or registration number, and the name of their insurer. If you never collected a certificate of insurance, ask for one now.
  4. Put it in writing. Email the contractor the same day: what was damaged, where, when you found it, the photos, and a request that they report it to their insurer. A text thread is evidence too, but a dated email is cleaner.
  5. Tell whoever is affected. The tenant, the next guest or the owner you manage for. If the unit can't be used, say so early, because lost rent or lost bookings belong in the claim.
  6. Get a repair quote from someone else. The contractor may offer to fix it themselves, and that can be fine, but an independent quote gives you a number to hold them to.

Who pays, case by case

The answer turns on who hired the crew, whose property was damaged, and whether the problem is damage the crew caused or bad work itself.

What happenedWho pays firstThe fallback
Your contractor damaged the building or your furniture The contractor, usually through its general liability policy Your own property policy, depending on its terms and your deductible
Your contractor damaged a tenant's belongings The contractor, on the tenant's claim The tenant's renters policy. Your landlord policy does not cover their things.
The work itself is faulty (a new fitting leaks) The contractor, under the contract: redo it or refund it The license bond, in states that require one
The faulty work damaged other things (the ceiling below the leak) The contractor, through its liability insurance Your own property policy, depending on its terms
A vendor damaged a short-term rental between guests The vendor Your own policy, depending on its terms. Airbnb's damage protection is for guest damage.
You manage the home for an owner and your vendor damaged it The vendor Whatever your management agreement says about vendor damage

Tenant belongings are a common mistake. A landlord policy insures the landlord's building. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department (pa.gov) tells renters that "just because your landlord insures the space you rent does not mean that you are covered." So when a painter ruins a tenant's sofa, the useful thing you can do is hand the tenant the contractor's details and insurer, confirm in writing what you saw, and keep your own record. Check what your lease says about access and damage before you promise anything.

Short-term rentals add one wrinkle. Airbnb's help center (airbnb.com) says its host damage protection "covers you if a guest damages your place or belongings during an Airbnb stay." A plumber who cracks a vanity between two stays is not a guest, so that claim belongs with the plumber. If the damage could have come from the last guest or the crew, the timing of your records decides which claim you can file, and Airbnb claims have their own deadline. Our comparison of AirCover, Proper, Safely and Vrbo covers what each program pays.

Homes you manage for an owner follow the same chain, but the owner hears about it from you. Tell them early, with the record and the claim already open. Our guide on how to tell an owner their property was damaged walks through that conversation.

What the contractor's insurance and bond actually cover

Two different tools stand behind a licensed contractor, and they do different jobs.

General liability insurance

This is the policy that pays for damage a contractor's work causes to other people's property. AIA Contract Documents (aiacontracts.com), the contract program of the American Institute of Architects, describes it this way: "CGL coverage is 'third-party' coverage, meaning it covers claims from those other than the policy holder(s)." AIA's standard insurance exhibit asks the contractor's policy to cover "damages because of physical damage to, or destruction of, tangible property, including the loss of use of such property." That last phrase matters to rental owners: rent or bookings lost while a unit is repaired can count as a loss of use, so put it in your claim and in your contract.

Requirements vary by state, and where a state sets a minimum, it can be low. Washington, for example, requires registered contractors to carry $200,000 in public liability and $50,000 in property damage coverage, or a $250,000 combined single limit, according to the Washington State Department of Labor & Industries (lni.wa.gov). Ask what the policy limit is, not only whether a policy exists.

The license bond

A bond is not the contractor's insurance. It is a fixed sum backed by a surety company, built around license-law violations and bad work, and how you claim it depends on the state.

  • California: the Contractors State License Board (cslb.ca.gov) requires a $25,000 contractor's bond, "filed for the benefit of consumers who may be damaged as a result of defective construction or other license law violations." CSLB does not process bond claims; consumers file with the surety, which CSLB's license detail page names under the contractor's bond history.
  • Washington: state law requires a $30,000 bond for general contractors and $15,000 for specialty contractors, conditioned in part on paying "all amounts that may be adjudged against the contractor by reason of breach of contract including improper work," according to the Revised Code of Washington, section 18.27.040 (leg.wa.gov). To claim it, you sue the contractor and the bond in superior court; a homeowner's breach-of-contract action must be filed within two years of the work being substantially completed or abandoned.

For a job that went wrong, the bond is a backstop. For damage a careful crew caused by accident, the liability policy is the main route, subject to its terms.

The proof that decides it

Most contractor damage disputes turn on one question: was it like that before the crew arrived? The contractor's insurer will ask you the same thing. What settles it is a pair of records of the same rooms, one before the job and one after.

  • A before record of the work area and the path in. Photos or a walkthrough video of the rooms the crew will touch, plus hallways, stairs, door frames and floors along the route the crew carries tools and materials through.
  • Times you can trust. Photos carry a capture date in their metadata, and our guide on how to check when a photo was taken shows how to read it. Some ways of sending a photo strip that date, so keep the originals.
  • The work order and the schedule. What the crew was hired to do, where, and when they arrived and left. Smart lock or access logs help here.
  • The after record, from the same angles. A matching pair is easy for an insurer to follow.

If the unit is occupied, plan the before record into your entry notice. Rules on notice vary by state. In Florida, for example, "reasonable notice" for entry to make repairs is at least 24 hours, and a reasonable time for a repair entry is between 7:30 a.m. and 8:00 p.m., according to Florida Statutes section 83.53 (leg.state.fl.us). The same visit can capture the before record.

Set it up before the next job

  • Collect a certificate of insurance before work starts, and check that it is current and that the limit makes sense for the job. Our post on whether your inspector needs insurance shows how to verify a certificate in five minutes.
  • Check the license and bond on your state's licensing board site, where one exists.
  • Write a short scope with a damage clause. Name the work area and the path in, say that the contractor is responsible for damage they cause there, and include loss of use, meaning rent or bookings lost while the damage is repaired.
  • Record the unit before the crew arrives and after they leave. The same walkthrough, the same angles, every time. That habit wins the dispute you haven't had yet.

Quick FAQ

Who pays if a contractor damages my rental property?

Usually the contractor. Damage a crew causes while it works is normally a claim against the contractor, and contractors commonly carry general liability insurance for damage to other people's property; some states require it. Whether that policy pays depends on its terms. Send the claim to the contractor in writing, with photos of the damage and a record of the unit before the job, and ask them to report it to their insurer. Your own policy is the fallback if they will not or cannot pay.

Is a contractor responsible for damage to a tenant's belongings?

If the crew caused it, the tenant's claim is against the contractor, and you should pass the contractor's details and insurer to the tenant. Your landlord policy covers your building, not the tenant's things. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department puts it plainly: just because the landlord insures the space a tenant rents does not mean the tenant is covered. A tenant's own renters policy is their other route.

Can I claim lost rent or lost bookings from a contractor?

You can ask, and you should put the number in your written claim. The AIA's standard construction insurance exhibit asks a contractor's general liability policy to cover damage to tangible property including the loss of use of that property. Whether a given policy pays depends on its terms, so the stronger move is to write loss of use into your contract before the job.

What if the contractor has no insurance?

Check whether the contractor is licensed and bonded. In California, the $25,000 contractor's bond is filed for the benefit of consumers damaged by defective construction or other license law violations, and you file the claim with the surety company. Washington requires a $30,000 bond for general contractors and $15,000 for specialty contractors, and you claim it by suing the contractor and the bond in superior court. A bond usually helps only when the damage comes from defective work or a license-law violation, not from a plain accident. If there is no bond or insurance, the remaining routes are usually your own policy and a court claim against the contractor.

How do I prove a contractor caused the damage?

With a dated record of the same rooms before the job and after it. Photos or a video walkthrough taken before the crew arrives, covering the rooms they work in and the path they use to get there, turn the argument about whether a mark was already there into a comparison. Add the work order, the arrival and finish times, and your written notice to the contractor. Our guide on what makes photo evidence hold up covers the same logic for tenant disputes.

Sources

Sources are named at the publisher level with their root domain, rather than linked or titled; every figure is verifiable at the named source.

  1. Contractor's bond requirements and bond claim guidance, Contractors State License Board (California)cslb.ca.gov
  2. Contractor registration requirements, Washington State Department of Labor & Industrieslni.wa.gov
  3. Revised Code of Washington, section 18.27.040 (contractor bonds), Washington State Legislatureleg.wa.gov
  4. Guidance on commercial general liability insurance and the AIA insurance exhibit, AIA Contract Documents, 2022aiacontracts.com
  5. Consumer guidance on renters insurance, Pennsylvania Insurance Departmentpa.gov
  6. Florida Statutes section 83.53, Florida Legislatureleg.state.fl.us
  7. Host damage protection guidance for hosts, Airbnb, 2026airbnb.com

Keep reading